Posts

Identifying Arguments

So relevant truth becomes an issue. Identifying Arguments Arguments are composed of premises and a conclusion, where the premises are said to support, prove, or provide evidence for the conclusion. Grammar, punctuation, and reading comprehension Consider the following statement from Thomas Hobbes's Leviathan: Whensoever a man transferreth his right, or renounceth it; it is either in consideration of some right reciprocally transferred to himself, or for some other good he hopeth for thereby. For "it" is a voluntary act; and of the voluntary acts of every man, the object is some good to himself. Let us begin by asking what does the underscored word "it" refer to? An understanding of the pronoun "it" is absolutely essential to an understanding of Hobbes's argument. The pronoun "it" refers to the whole phrase "whensoever a man transferreth his right, or renounces it." How do we know this? To began with, a pronoun refers to an ...

Argument Intro

Law of the excluded middle. This law states that every statement is either true or false. (1) Communists support unilateral disarmament. (2) Liberals support unilateral disarmament. ______________________________________ (3) Therefore, Liberals are Communists. Most of us would agree that statements (1) and (2) are true but that statement (3) is false. But the argument seems to imply that if statements (1) and (2) are true then statement (3) must be true. Since this argument is puzzling, let us schematize it and then analyze its content. We shall adopt the following symbols: "C" stands for Communists "L" stands for Liberals "V" stands for "supports unilateral nuclear disarmament." In schematic form the argument now looks like this: (1) C is V (2) L is V (3) L is C In order to test the accountability of the above argument, we now construct another argument with the same schematic form. (1) All camels are vegetarians (2) Lambs are ...

Reading Requirements

Nicholas Capaldi - How to Win Every Argument Michael P. Maslanka FORD & HARRISON LLP - THE ART OF PERSUASION OR HOW I LEARNED TO START LOVING THE REPTILE BRAIN www.hrhero.com MICHAEL P. MASLANKA - GETTING THE ANSWERS YOU WANT: EFFECTIVE DEPOSITION TECHNIQUES EFFECTIVE DEPOSITION PREPRATION www.mmaslanka@fordharrison.com

4 Principles of Unconventional Warfare

1. Work outside the enemy's experience This ability imposes chaos and disorder on the enemy, which cannot orient itself to novelty and collapses in the process. What they might have read or heard about matters less than their personal experience, which dominates their emotional lives and determines their responses. 2. Unfold the extraordinary out of the ordinary To Sun-Tzu and the ancient Chinese, doing something extraordinary has little effect without a setup of something ordinary. You had to merge the two to fix your opponents' expectations with some banal,ordinary maneuver a comfortable pattern that they would expect you to follow. Mesmerized, you would then hit them with the extraordinary, a show of stunning force from and entirely new angle. Framed by the predictable, the blow would have double the impact. Ordinary strategy that he had used earlier to fix their attention and use it for his main attack, for that would be the last thing the enemy would expect. And so...

6 Main Forms of Military Deception

1. The false front Involved making the enemy believe that one was weaker than in fact was the case. The appearance of weakness often brings out people's aggressive side, making them drop strategy and prudence for an emotional and violent attack. Controlling the front you present to the world is the most critical deceptive skill. Instead you need to present a front that does the opposite-disarms suspicions. The best front here is weakness, which will make the other side feel superior to you, so that they either ignore you (and being ignored is very valuable at times) or are baited into an aggressive action at the wrong moment. Once it is too late, once they are committed, they can find out the hard way that you are not so weak after all. Making people think they are better than you are-smarter, stronger, more competent-is often wise, gives you breathing space to lay your plans, to manipulate. In a variation of this strategy, the front of virtue, honesty, and uprightness is o...

4 Principles of Maneuver warfare

1. Craft a plan with branches A plan with branches lets you out-maneuver your enemy because your responses to changing circumstances are faster and more rational. 2. Give yourself room to maneuver Consider the ability to move and keeping open more options than your enemy has as more important than keeping territories or possessions. You want open space, not dead positions. This means not burdening yourself with commitments that will limit your options. The need for space is psychological as well as physical; you must have an unfettered mind to create anything worthwhile. 3. Give your enemy dilemmas, not problems But a dilemma is different; whatever they do, however they respond, retreat, advance, stay still-they are still in trouble. Make every option bad; if you maneuver quickly to a point, for instance, you can force your enemies either to fight before they are ready or to retreat. They constantly are put in positions that seem alluring but are traps. 4. Create maximum disor...

4 basic principles of Forcing

1. Keep them on their heels. Keep your enemies on the defensive and in reaction mode. In order to have rest oneself it is necessary to keep the enemy occupied. This throws them back on the defensive, and once they are placed that way they cannot rise up again during the campaign. Fredrick the Great (1712-1786) HARD PRESSED ON MY RIGHT; MY LEFT IS IN RETREAT. MY CENTER IS YIELDING. IMPOSSIBLE TO MANEUVER. SITUATION EXCELLENT. I AM ATTACKING. ATTAQUEZ! GENERAL FERDINAND FOCH, DURING THE BATTLE OF THE MARNE 2. Shift the battlefield Subtly shift your enemies into places and situations that are not familiar to them, you control the dynamic. Without realizing what is happening, your opponents find themselves fighting on your terms. 3. Compel mistakes Your task is twofold: to fight the battle in such a way that they cannot bring their strength or strategy into play and to create such a level of frustration that they make mistakes in the process. You do not give them enough time to...